The thing is, asking that question is like saying what's better, four quarters of a pizza or the whole pizza. Either way, you're stuffed afterwards. There's good pizza and there's bad pizza, doesn't matter how you cut it.
Everyone's favorite bass tube is Bazooka, plus you can get one that looks like a Nitrous bottle.I've seen people win SPL competitions using Bazooka Tubes before, so you can't say that all "tube" sub boxes suck, since the sub doesn't care what shape the box is, as long as it's the right size.
I used to have a couple of Earthquake 8" subs. The bloody magnets were bigger than the baskets. I threw them in a couple of old junk bass cannons (Collins Audio Productions, if anyone's heard of them) and they still pounded. The tubes were these horrible things looked like they were made of cardboard (actually particle board, I think) but the speakers still pumped.
Anyway, I still think the shape of the box isn't nearly as important as the design. If the cylinder shape is easier for you to haul around, go with it. If you need huge, make-your-vision-blurry bass, then you might want a box bigger than any of the cannons offer. Try a demo at a stereo shop to make up your mind.
Regards,
Kris



LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks

Reply With Quote









Bookmarks