Page 4 of 13 FirstFirst 12345678910111213 LastLast
Results 31 to 40 of 122

Thread: Calculating MPG from VSS and MAF from OBD2

  1. #31
    North of the land of Hey Huns
    Auto Apps:loading...

    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Westminster, MD
    Posts
    2,127
    I'd say probably, as a diesel engine pushes more fuel for more power, rather than more air, and dosent try to obtain a stoimetric air/fuel ratio of 14.7:1.


    However, because your fuel usage is directly affected by your throttle position, perhaps there is a way to figure it out that way?

  2. #32
    pwb
    pwb is offline
    Newbie
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Posts
    23
    I think Scangauge is reading this values

    0C - RPM
    04 - Load
    05 - Engine coolant temp
    0B - MAP
    0F - Intake air temp

    But how to calculate this to get MPG etc. ?

    /pwb

  3. #33
    Low Bitrate Skidd's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    49
    Quote Originally Posted by dreadknought View Post
    as many have posted already, the formulas given here are for stoichiometric fuel ratios. Unfortunately, modern cars don't run at stoichiometric fuel ratios. They run as lean as possible, just on the cusp of lean missing when cruising. They run rich anywhere from half-throttle to WOT. They automatically compensate for sub-standard fuels and fuel additives that affect octane.

    My suggestion is, use the formula for calculating stoichiometric fuel consumption, but use the LTFT (Long Term Fuel Trim) to find what the vehicle is actually using. LTFT is given in +/- % (percentage). An example of the formula to use is

    MPG = (14.7 * (1 + LTFT/100) * 6.17 * 454 * VSS * 0.621371) / (3600 * MAF / 100)
    MPG = 710.7 * VSS / MAF * (1 + LTFT/100)

    This formula uses the car's fuel trim value to compensate for the difference in actual AFR and stoichiometric AFR, however I'm not 100% sure that the LTFT value is % difference from stoichiometric. If anybody has any ideas as to how correct my thoughts are, please respond.

    I just wanted to chime in and let you know that LTFT can't be used to adjust for the ECU changing it's target AF ratio. The LTFT is not an indication of a different AF ratio, it's an adjustment made because the ECU learned through the STFT that more or less fuel is needed for a given rpm/load point. The LTFT is a percentage of fuel removed from the expected amount required.

    For example, I have a 2000 subaru impreza 2.5RS. I've put in a mild set of aftermarket cams. As a result, vacuum at idle is much lower than what the ECU was pre-programmed to expect. The STFT was pulling -25% fuel at idle while the LTFT was still at 0. Over time, the LTFT adjusted from 0%, to -25% and now the STFT hovers betwen +- 5%.

    so.. the LTFT helps the ECU achieve it's target AF ratio by remembering and learning wha the STFT has found while driving. But, at no point was the target AF ratio ever known. The idle target AF could have been as lean as 18:1 in my car. No way to know from the LTFT calculation.


    P.S. On a side note, your MPG formula has helped me out tremendously! I've implemented it in a program that I'm writing for OBD2 (and other protocols) display.
    http://jdash.ludicrous-speed.com/for....php?f=11&t=63

    Shane.

  4. #34
    Newbie
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    1

    MPG Calculations

    What if you do not have MAF sensor to calc from? I have a honda Civic 1999 with no MAF sensor readout but it has Air Pressure. Would I be SOL?

  5. #35
    Low Bitrate Skidd's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    49
    Quote Originally Posted by Takiyon View Post
    What if you do not have MAF sensor to calc from? I have a honda Civic 1999 with no MAF sensor readout but it has Air Pressure. Would I be SOL?
    Perhaps not.. My 2000 Subaru Impreza also does not have a MAF sensor, but the ECU returns an accurate MAF value. I guess it calculates it based on the other parameters, and generates a virtual MAF signal. So, if your car does the same, you'll be good to go.

  6. #36
    Low Bitrate
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    95
    unless you car is carbureted there's a measurement of airflow somewhere. some systems calculate the airflow based on air intake velocity/density/temperature, etc.

    here's a good read...

    http://www.ktarry.com/pub/techhtm/air_metering.htm
    2006 Corolla S Ex-Audio 7" Epia MII ATI AIW VE 512MB Mini-Box.com M300 Case 100GB 2.5" HDD Z-COM XI-325HP+ Linksys WSB24/WRT54G w DD-WRT Treo 755p BT Modem Lite-On Slotload DVD GPS JVC AVX2 2x JL Audio 8" Alpine Type-S F/R

  7. #37
    Low Bitrate
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    99
    Quote Originally Posted by Takiyon View Post
    What if you do not have MAF sensor to calc from? I have a honda Civic 1999 with no MAF sensor readout but it has Air Pressure. Would I be SOL?
    I know many Chryslers use MAP sensors and do not supply a MAF reading for OBD requests. There are corporate PIDs for Chrysler MAF, but here is a method for doing MPG without a MAF sensor. It is not as accurate, but it is OK. You will need to calculate a Pseudo MAF.

    MAP:
    MPG=((AirFuel*FuelDensityPounds*GramsPerPound*Spee dMPH))/((3600*MAF/100)))
    AirFuel=14.7
    Fuel Density=6
    GramsPerPound=454
    SpeedMPH=VSS(KPH)*.621371
    3600=seconds to hours conversion

    MAF=(MAP/IAT)*(MM/R)*(RPM/60)*(EngDisp/2)*VE
    MAP=Manifold Absolute Pressure from vehicle per J1979
    IAT(K)=IAT(C) from vehicle per J1979 +273
    MM=Molecular mass of air 28.97 g/mol
    R=Universal air constant 8.314 J/K/mol
    RPM= Revolutions per minute from vehicle per J1979
    EngDisp=Engine displacement in liters
    VE=Volumetric efficiency


    It's up to you to determine your VE as it varies across the powerband, but you can assume it is one value.

  8. #38
    Newbie split63's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    36
    disregard

  9. #39
    Low Bitrate
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    99
    Quote Originally Posted by split63 View Post
    With regard to working with a MAP sensor and having no MAF sensor. One post had a rough conversion between MAP and MAF as:
    Engine Mass Airflow= RPM * ( MAP/Temp)
    Fuel Mass = Engine Mass Airflow / Stoichiometric Ratio

    Another post had this:

    IMAP = RPM * MAP / IAT (Same as above)
    MAF = (IMAP/120)*(VE/100)*(ED)*(MM)/(R)
    Where,
    R is 8.314 J/K/mole = universal gas constant
    MM is molecular mass or 28.97 g/mole
    ED = engine displacement in liters
    VE = Volumetric displacement

    Equating the two approaches, MAF= (IMAP/120)*(VE/100)*(ED)*(MM)/(R) = Engine Mass Airflow / Stoichiometric Ratio
    where IMAP = Engine Mass Airflow

    Reducing:
    1/Stoichiometric Ratio = (1/120)*(VE/100)*(ED)*(MM)/(R)

    or Stoichiometric Ratio =(120 * 100* R) / (VE * ED * MM)


    I'm at a lost to understand how the terms on the right equate to the Stoichiometric ratio, even roughly.


    Assuming the more complex equation is correct/accurate, it can be reduced to MAF = RPM * (MAP/TEMP) * X

    Where X is a contant comprised of the constants R, MM, ED, and VE
    If this is the case, then X can be approximated and then scaled by actual mileage results. In which case, the value of VE and displacement are not important. However, I believe VE is reduced with RPM, so it would seem that a scaling factor is needed based on RPM and I'm not sure there is an easy way to generate this scale factor.
    The two equations should not be equated. You use MAP to generate a pseudo MAF. That pseudo MAF is then used in the "generic" MPG equation.

    MAF= (IMAP/120)*(VE/100)*(ED)*(MM)/(R)

    MPG= Engine Mass Airflow / Stoichiometric Ratio

    Note: I just corrected your approach. I did not check you numbers.

  10. #40
    Low Bitrate
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    95
    does anyone have and code or binaries they want to post that will work with an elm on windows?
    2006 Corolla S Ex-Audio 7" Epia MII ATI AIW VE 512MB Mini-Box.com M300 Case 100GB 2.5" HDD Z-COM XI-325HP+ Linksys WSB24/WRT54G w DD-WRT Treo 755p BT Modem Lite-On Slotload DVD GPS JVC AVX2 2x JL Audio 8" Alpine Type-S F/R

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •