Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

hybrid dual sproggys....

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • hybrid dual sproggys....

    Hey all, total newbie here!

    I've been following these posts for a while, and keep noticing that the sproggy in its current form wont work with a via epia m. While its 'with in limits' from what i read the start up draw is too large for a sproggy to handle.

    Is it then possible, and without a major redesign of the sproggy, to split the load between two of them? I know that there are dangers to running two in paralell, so why not split the two major voltages between them? Have one sproggy take care of the 3.3v (set it all to 3.3v, like the old sproggys were all 5v) and say the harddrive, dvd, ect 12+ and the other take care of the 5v and everything else. My electrical knowledge is limited to basically nothing, and so i couldnt even begin to design such a thing...

    On something slightly different, has anyone had any sucess with sproggys and the via epia v? Apart from ddr vs sd ram and the m looking better (imo anyway), the only real difference i can see is about AUD$100 in favour of the v series, which is a hell of an incentive for me to go that way.

    Hope this has been of help...

  • #2
    The startup current theory was mostly speculation.

    From what I could find, it is signal timing or voltage ramp up timing issue.

    I have a dual 787 and dual 788 sproggy and that does not solve the problem alone. I was able to power the m9000 with my unmodified sproggy 2.7 (dual 787 and single 788) on one occasion. I did it using a BASIC Stamp IC. I used the stamp to control the various signals (Power Good, PS_ON, actual sproggy power on, etc).

    I still haven't figured out the exact timing needed. The time I got it to power up, was actually due to a bug in my stamp code, where it was randomly power cycling the stamp chip restarting the startup sequence.

    My suggestion is to not waste your time with the sproggy if you want to power an M9000 or M10000. Just buy an Opus, or Magic Power (or wait until may and pickup a cheap 70w from mini-box.com).

    The sproggy is still useful for powering other motherboards, harddrives, assessories, etc.

    Comment


    • #3
      Thanks for that. Well that firmly blows designing a dc-dc to well out of my leauge! Looks like i'm stuck with either an inverter or prebuilt one.

      Does this happen with the epia v series though?

      Comment


      • #4
        Why not just strap a cheap microcontroller to the sproggy. What do you mean by you can't find the right timing? Surely you get just create the pulses without any highly specific timing, just as long as it's within the stated values in the ATX spec

        Comment


        • #5
          In theory it sounds like it should be easy.

          My sproggy powers a P3-933 motherboard perfectly, but try it with the M9000, and it fails to POST.

          I don't have an oscilloscope so I can't easily measure what is happening with the sproggy outputs and timing. It's probably something simple, but I wasn't able to figure it out. I just got tired wasting time on it. Wasting a few hours easily pays for an Opus.

          Comment


          • #6
            so its a timing issue, not a power one....

            doesnt that mean that the via wont work with any homebuilt device?

            Comment


            • #7
              Please correct me if I'm wrong but I believe sproggy simulates the power good signal with a simple r-c circuit and the waveform which is produced is violating atx specifcations.
              Power good signal must occur in under 1 second from turn on and over 0.1 seconds. This is simulated correctly by the r-c circuit (I hope). However atx specs also state that the power good signal must rise from 0v to 4.75v in 0.01 seconds which it definately does not.
              I imagine most boards don't care about the risetime but for some reason epia boards obviously do. A simple solution is to stick a not gate in swap around the resistor and capacitor, and adjust the values according to suit the change in voltage threshold on the gates input.

              Sorry if this info has been overdue but I do not know if this is the reason (since I have no sproggy or similar) but it's seems the most logical to me.

              Comment


              • #8
                well i sure wish VIA would help, I emailed them about it and they replied the usual "we dont care" attitude, ... "if your dc to dc supply is within the atx specs, it should work"
                No attempt to actually help with the problem and tell US the customer, what is actually happening, therefore saving our time and either fixing it, or just using a good off the shelf item. I have a EPIA M6000 and a sproggy and I simply can not get it to POST.
                Ford XR6T blueprint 4.0 L twin cam turbo.
                Xenarc 7" touchscreen M10000 Audigy 2 NX
                ITX 120W PS 80gig HD, 256MB Ram, USB wireless internet/LAN
                Griffin Powermate Panasonic DVD-CDW
                Pioneer 5x7 Four way, 2x12 pioneer subz
                600watt 6chan USA audio AMP

                Comment


                • #9
                  ITX SPROGGY power problems, FAILING TO BOOT

                  Oh, and I have just heard a whisper of another thing. It appears that the EPIA M mainboards like 3.0volts, not 3.3v. Can anyone else confirm this?
                  Could this be why Mine wont boot?
                  Please help me dudes:P I dont want to fork out for an Opus. Especially since it looks like it wont work with that either!!
                  Ford XR6T blueprint 4.0 L twin cam turbo.
                  Xenarc 7" touchscreen M10000 Audigy 2 NX
                  ITX 120W PS 80gig HD, 256MB Ram, USB wireless internet/LAN
                  Griffin Powermate Panasonic DVD-CDW
                  Pioneer 5x7 Four way, 2x12 pioneer subz
                  600watt 6chan USA audio AMP

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by stimps
                    well i sure wish VIA would help, I emailed them about it and they replied the usual "we dont care" attitude, ... "if your dc to dc supply is within the atx specs, it should work"
                    No attempt to actually help with the problem and tell US the customer, what is actually happening, therefore saving our time and either fixing it, or just using a good off the shelf item. I have a EPIA M6000 and a sproggy and I simply can not get it to POST.
                    No disrespect intended, but it is your power supply that is at fault, not their motherboard. Why should they help debug your power supply for you?


                    Rob
                    Old Systems retired due to new car
                    New system at design/prototype stage on BeagleBoard.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      I know its my power supply at fault, thats why im TRYING to fix it. Thanks for you help:P But one thing that sticks in my mind is this. Why does this sproggy supply i have biult, work with any other atx motherboard, but not an EPIA????? Did you ever think of that Rob withey??
                      Ford XR6T blueprint 4.0 L twin cam turbo.
                      Xenarc 7" touchscreen M10000 Audigy 2 NX
                      ITX 120W PS 80gig HD, 256MB Ram, USB wireless internet/LAN
                      Griffin Powermate Panasonic DVD-CDW
                      Pioneer 5x7 Four way, 2x12 pioneer subz
                      600watt 6chan USA audio AMP

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Yep, simply because other boards are not so fussy on the ATX spec. Your Epia works with a standard ATX power supply, right?

                        Did you ever think about that, stimps??


                        Rob
                        Old Systems retired due to new car
                        New system at design/prototype stage on BeagleBoard.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          of course you friggin twit.
                          Ford XR6T blueprint 4.0 L twin cam turbo.
                          Xenarc 7" touchscreen M10000 Audigy 2 NX
                          ITX 120W PS 80gig HD, 256MB Ram, USB wireless internet/LAN
                          Griffin Powermate Panasonic DVD-CDW
                          Pioneer 5x7 Four way, 2x12 pioneer subz
                          600watt 6chan USA audio AMP

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by stimps
                            of course you friggin twit.

                            Oooh, temper temper. I'll refrain from stooping to your level and instead offer you some free advice.

                            You're a newbie here. You don't get things for free, especially from manufacturers. I have been in the mp3car business for 4 years now. I have setup that I planned, designed and built and got it right from the start and that has changed very little in that time. As for me being a twit, I suggest you look at who is still fumbling with power supplies and is expecting freebie support from a manufacturer on a product you didn't even buy from them.

                            I wish you luck.


                            Rob
                            Old Systems retired due to new car
                            New system at design/prototype stage on BeagleBoard.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Rob Withey
                              No disrespect intended, but it is your power supply that is at fault, not their motherboard. Why should they help debug your power supply for you?


                              Rob
                              mate, your the one who started this, so just **** right off. All i was looking for was some constructive help. Not destructive critisim. If you dont have anything to add, just shut the **** up.
                              Ford XR6T blueprint 4.0 L twin cam turbo.
                              Xenarc 7" touchscreen M10000 Audigy 2 NX
                              ITX 120W PS 80gig HD, 256MB Ram, USB wireless internet/LAN
                              Griffin Powermate Panasonic DVD-CDW
                              Pioneer 5x7 Four way, 2x12 pioneer subz
                              600watt 6chan USA audio AMP

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X