Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2nd Battery not preforming like I expected.

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 2nd Battery not preforming like I expected.

    Alright guys here's the deal:

    I take my car to the local drive in regularly, and was using my carputer for the radio, but my problem is after about 1.5 movies the battery is dead. Im running an i5 with a 40w kenwood amp and hd radio. So my thoughts were simple as this. Wire in a 2nd battery, extend computer life to last 2-2.5 movies. Well, I wired it in, and the computer still cuts off about 2 hours into the night.


    My batteries are wired directly to each other. + to + / - to - with fuses in the appropriate places. No isolator or switcher, because Im using the same sized battery, with power being pulled off the + terminal of the 2nd battery.


    Am I just stupid for thinking it would work this way? Or.... is something wrong?

  • #2
    You are making both batteries half dead as when one goes down it draws current from the other battery til they are both below starting voltage you really need to isolate them and also work on your amperage draw from amp, hd radio, computer p/s, hubs ect. SNO

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by SNOtwistR View Post
      You are making both batteries half dead as when one goes down it draws current from the other battery til they are both below starting voltage you really need to isolate them and also work on your amperage draw from amp, hd radio, computer p/s, hubs ect. SNO
      Trick is the car starts fine. When I say dead I mean to the point where the computer cuts off, I can turn the car and it starts without a hickup. So Im guessing the m4 is reading below 12v and shutting it off? I dont think there is much I can do to reduce the draw from my current setup. I was hoping as 1 got lower, the other would re-charge it. But that apparently not the way I thought.

      Comment


      • #4
        Correct me if I am wrong:

        But wouldn't installing a isolator cut off the batteries from each other, giving me the 1.5 hour problem I was having originally?

        Comment


        • #5
          Iím not going to comment on the batteries as that subject has been done to death on here.

          The M4 has adjustable low voltage cut-off. Almost everything is adjustable with the M4 app and USB connection.

          BTW There are two M4 apps, one is more powerful (dangerous) than that other.
          Palm sized ainol MiniPC, 8" Transreflective PRO, Win10, Reverse camera, Dual 10HZ GPS RX's for Speed Display & Sat Nav, FM-DAB & Phone Modules, iDrive interface. T-Screen HVAC control, custom microcontrollers, microcode and FE.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by raggedrebel92 View Post
            No isolator or switcher, because Im using the same sized battery...?
            The size of the battery has little to do with using an isolator.

            I'd suggest an isolator (search mp3car for "UIBI" if you have a charge light) and a bigger 2nd battery. At least then you will still be able to crank.


            Be aware that as a general rule to meet warrantied life, cranking batteries should not be discharged more than 20% (~0.2V) and deep cycles 50% (~0.5V).

            Another PSU might help noting that some operate down to 6V which is way lower than you would want.

            Comment


            • #7
              Crap. I just realized, I've been saying m4. Thats from my original setup. I have the m3 now. Sorry guys!



              Oldspark, Just the guy I was looking to hear from. Both my batteries are 65 Class, so I don't want to go much bigger as I had a hard enough time finding a 65 class battery box. (and I'm not really sure what is available in bigger sizes).

              I can crank and start my car fine. The car starts just as if it has a full battery, its just my pc cuts off and will not restart unless the car is started.

              Im kinda thinking like what was said above that I may just need to reprogram my m3.


              By the way, nice to see someone else up this early!

              Comment


              • #8
                Thanks for the compliment, though Zulu time is ~9:20pm. My last reply was 7:30pm (Monday 10Sep2012).

                And I missed the m4 altogether! My bad. In that case, yeah - reprogram its dropout voltage.


                FYI...
                Group 65 - ie, ~70-75AH. By my reckoning, that suggests a 15A load for 1.5hrs to reach an open-circuit voltage of 12.0V (~50-60% discharged). But the actual voltage will be lower due to battery internal resistance so I expect your load is much less... maybe 5A - 10A?

                To use the ROT that each 0.1V drop is ~10% discharge (ie, assumes flat is ~11.6V & full is ~12.6-12.7V), I measure the full open-circuit voltage (after resting - ie, no surface charge) to confirm ~12.7V (12.67V in theory). I then add the load and remeasure to get the "loaded voltage reading" with the fully charged battery. EG - if full OC = 12.6V which drops to 12.3 with the load, I know that the loaded 12.3V corresponds to 100% fully charged.
                If I want to limit it to 30% discharge, then I'll set the cut-out voltage for 12.0V (ie, 12.3V full LESS (3 x 0.1V = ) 0.3V = 12.0V. (And I might go to 30% for a cranker knowing that it will soon be recharged by the alternator, else the battery won't live as long as intended.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Things to realize when using two batteries.. They MUST be the same brand and model and hopefully same age/condition or you will have one being preferred over the other and your system will only be marginally better. This bias also happens with charging as well. When running two batteries you also double the internal resistance. If you separate the batteries and use a constant rated solenoid to charge them you may find it actually lasts longer due to the less internal resistance. You can also use ultra high quality batteries as well. Some of these are about 50% the size of a standard battery of the same rating and some can be used like a deep cycle battery as well. Lead Acid batteries are a fickle thing and unless you are familiar with how they are setup they will surprise you in how they interact. If you use a Passive battery isolator they generally use large Diodes to separate batteries and the problem with diodes is that they generally drop .7 volts out of the circuit per Diode. Most alternators that are setup to charge 2 batteries have the diodes internally and are designed to charge at the proper voltage. Do not get an Optima Battery, these are NOT designed for automotive use although you will find many people using them.

                  Ultra high quality batteries can generally be purchased in the neighborhood of $200 but they are much more durable than a standard car battery and you can do things with them you can't do with a standard car battery. You do NOT want to use a Ultra high quality battery with a standard car battery.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    redheadrod, surely you jest...

                    Although battery differences are why you do not keep them paralleled (nor mix in series), those difference mean little during charging. And when being loaded, paralleling will increase capacity unless one is faulty or at a different capacity (percentage-wise, not AH-wise).


                    Two batteries in parallel halves the internal resistance. Or rather, the internal resistance is the same but are combined the same as 2 parallel resistances (which is always LESS than either of the individual resistances).


                    I am unaware of any alternator that uses diodes to charge 2 batteries. That requires 2 rotors and stators - ie, 2 alternators.
                    Alternators output up to 14.4V (steady-state) for 12V lead acids. [ 14.2V is a common set point. The older 13.8V spec has long been discarded. ] Alternators don't care what loads they power - it could be several paralleled 12V batteries - provided the alternator is loaded within its specs.

                    Who the heck uses diode isolators? Even in the old days, clever people used relays for battery isolation. (Which battery's voltage should the alternator sense?)
                    These days MOSFETs might be used instead of diodes, though I would still ask why (when a relay can be used...)?


                    Your other points seem subjective else without any definition (eg "quality", or what outlasts a car battery in a car {and why would it be preferred}?).

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      I really recommend that you pick up a current sensor ("fuse tester") - I got one at Harbor Freight for under $15:

                      http://www.harborfreight.com/30-amp-...ter-67724.html
                      http://www.harborfreight.com/20-amp-...ter-67725.html

                      All you do is plug this little guy in place of your blade fuse, put the fuse into the tester, and then start up the PC. This will give you a readout of how many amps the PC is using, and you can use it to determine how long you should be able to run off of battery power. It might help you diagnose any problems with your setup - maybe it's pulling way more amperage than you are expecting? You should also use a multimeter and determine what voltage the battery is operating at, and see if it cuts off a specific voltage.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by OldSpark View Post
                        redheadrod, surely you jest...

                        Although battery differences are why you do not keep them paralleled (nor mix in series), those difference mean little during charging. And when being loaded, paralleling will increase capacity unless one is faulty or at a different capacity (percentage-wise, not AH-wise).
                        This link explains why you want to use similar batteries way better than I could...
                        http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/a...configurations

                        Two batteries in parallel halves the internal resistance. Or rather, the internal resistance is the same but are combined the same as 2 parallel resistances (which is always LESS than either of the individual resistances).
                        I find this confusing...
                        I went through training with Metra a few years back and we spent some time with Batteries...
                        I just looked some and I am finding that you are correct but we had a demonstration that would make you believe otherwise. Something other than internal resistance must have been at work with the demonstration we had.

                        It was a demonstration on why it can be a bad idea to use two batteries in parallel. The over all capacity is more but not 2x more as you might think.
                        They pushed that you really wanted to isolate the batteries from each other at any time other than charging.

                        We had 2 partially charged batteries of the same type and model and hooked them in parallel to a car. The car would not start.. Would not even crank over.
                        When you used just one of the batteries the car would crank over slowly but would start. This happened with both batteries.
                        So apparently it must not have been an internal resistance issue as I have thought for a few years now but something else entirely.

                        I have also seen reference to this when jumping a car as well.

                        I am unaware of any alternator that uses diodes to charge 2 batteries. That requires 2 rotors and stators - ie, 2 alternators.
                        Alternators output up to 14.4V (steady-state) for 12V lead acids. [ 14.2V is a common set point. The older 13.8V spec has long been discarded. ] Alternators don't care what loads they power - it could be several paralleled 12V batteries - provided the alternator is loaded within its specs.
                        I HAVE one here... It is made by Wrangler. It is 130 AMP Hot/Cold rated GM compatible alternator with external Voltage Regulator. It has TWO outputs for batteries.
                        if you are using it with just one battery you MUST hook it to both posts with another wire. It is in storage so I could probably take a picture of it but I purchased it used and I believe the web site for the manufacturer is www.wranglerpower.com but I am not 100% certain since I do not see this alternator offered anymore.

                        Who the heck uses diode isolators? Even in the old days, clever people used relays for battery isolation. (Which battery's voltage should the alternator sense?)
                        These days MOSFETs might be used instead of diodes, though I would still ask why (when a relay can be used...)?
                        I had one of these and I may still have it around somewhere. They had huge heat sinks on them and for proper use you had to tweak the voltage on your alternator higher to overcome the drop in voltage. It looked much like an audio amplifier. The large Diodes were potted inside the large heat sink and you had 3 connections. The common or Feed and then one each for each battery. Because I couldn't get my alternator voltage up I ended up replacing this with a constant on RV solenoid.
                        Relays are a bad idea unless you can get a very large Relay. RV constant use Solenoids are similar to starter solenoids but designed to be on constantly with large current capacities and for use in a dual battery system.

                        If you do a Google search for "Battery Isolator" you will find MANY of the diode style of isolator. It is very cheap and requires no extra hardware to run and won't wear out.
                        Probably used much more in Marine use than anything else.

                        Your other points seem subjective else without any definition (eg "quality", or what outlasts a car battery in a car {and why would it be preferred}?).
                        Most of the companies I remember selling batteries made with "Ultra Pure" copper plates and similar designs don't appear to exist anymore. (US AMPS used to make some awesome batteries)
                        It appears that to get the type of batteries I was talking about you need either an Odyssey or Kinetik type battery but I am not as familiar with these as the older style batteries.

                        I had a long talk with one of the engineers for the Wrangler Alternator I had and he explained why the Optima Battery is a very BAD battery for car audio. He was the one that mentioned the US AMP battery.

                        What he told me is that the Optima Battery was designed for Off Road use mainly and for some racing applications. If used as the main battery in a car it will destroy your alternator eventually. Reason why is because as it discharges the design of it falsely requires higher and higher amperage to charge it. He told me a near dead battery shows to an alternator as a nearly 400 amp load and if you COULD charge it at that rate you would blow it up. Otherwise at this rate you will put a tremendous load on your alternator. He told me he could take a near dead optima battery and recharge it without issue but required a current limited charger which is not cheap. I went through 5 red top batteries and 2 alternators before I talked to this guy and it all made sense so I dumped the Optimas and got a US AMP battery. Doesn't matter now but that battery worked as well as the Optima battery, was half the size and I had NO issues with it even after 5 years using it as my main battery. I never had dimming headlights while feeding over 500 watts to my Subs or the other 200 watts to the other speakers.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          That Battery University stuff does not refer to rechargeable batteries. However the issues about being matched when still connected by unused (or loaded) are the same, hence why we isolate parallel batteries when NOT being charged. If users need to parallel them for extra capacity or lower monoblock stress, then fine -but they should otherwise remain isolated (except if charging).
                          When charging, only the voltage and type of battery needs to be matched (ie, 12V, lead-acid), their capacity, brand, and history & age does not matter. (That's in with consideration of the usual norms - eg, don't connect a faulty battery; follow precautions or recommendations if paralleling discharged and charged batteries; temperatures are similar; etc.)


                          2 batteries in series ADDs the internal resistances, but in parallel it's the normal "parallel resistance".
                          And surprise surprise, a battery is often modeled as a VERY large cap, and parallel battery capacities are added just as capacitance is.
                          EG - two paralleled 12V 100AH batteries each with 10mΩ internal resistance is equivalent to a 12V 200AH with 5mΩ internal resistance. Same voltage, double the fault/short current, etc.
                          (fyi - the "surprise" is not mocking - it is merely intended at my surprise that the common "model" works in parallel mode. However in series...)


                          Again, yes, isolate paralleled batteries when NOT charging.
                          The reason is that they will not be the same, and whichever is "lower" will drag down the other. (The "higher" does not "hold up" the lower, the lower discharges the higher.)
                          Though matching or luck may minimise the differences, eventually one fails and kills the other; or thermal runaway (mainly in AGMs) occurs, etc.


                          Simple reliability consideration:
                          If one battery lasts 10 years (ie, 10 year lifespan or MTBF) and you have 2 of them, you replace 2 batteries in 10 years.
                          Connect them in parallel, yo replace four batteries in 10 years. (ie, one fails after 5 years and kills the other so you replace both. The same again in 5 years.)
                          But the above is VERY simplified and far from reality. The MTBF is the MTBF for a single battery in that environment with flat distribution. The increased failure rate due to interactive failure is ignored. ETC.
                          The main point is that unlike the typical reliability of interconnected components, interconnected batteries interact with each other and a faulty battery will cause earlier failure in the others (including series connected batteries).


                          Diode isolators. Alas I find they are far more expensive than relays. (Relays being "electrical isolators" and include solenoids {yes, I understand THAT ambiguity!}, contactors, etc.)
                          But my main reason against them - WHICH battery do you connect the alternator's Sense terminal or tweak the alternator voltage to?
                          If it's a manual tweak (not using the alternator's Sense), what current is passing thru that diode? Is the diode drop 0.6V @ 1A, 0.7V @ 5A, 1.0V @ 20A, or 1.5V @ 40A? etc. IE - undercharge the battery under load (and supply a mere 13.3V to loads?), or cook the at low loads?
                          And is the sense wire is used, and the current to the other battery & load is different, then does it cook or undercharge?
                          MOSFETs are better, but do they have as low a contact voltage as a relay? (And withstand vehicle surges?)



                          Hmmm - copper plates in bateries. You mean lead?
                          Apparently Optima started using recycled or non-pure lead which may have been one of their alleged downfalls.
                          But I haven't been recommending Optima, and on this site, "Optima Jim" who was their eMarketing Manager (or whatever) for a while did little to counter what I had heard. Then again, he reckoned paralleling Optima batteries had no effect on their reliability...
                          Their construction is supposedly "suited" to the rough stuff. Alas I merely drive road cars and broke wheel rims and shock-absorbers etc because I speed up on rough dirt roads, but my batteries have all been fine (though the wets may spill acid when upside down).
                          I did run when I dropped my 13 year old Yuasa 38AH UPS AGM battery (UXH38-12) from higher than 1m and its corner hit the concrete, but it didn't explode and it's still in my ute as the main cranker.
                          Not that AGMs should be used for cranking, but my old wet cranker failed 2 to 3 years ago and I had the UXH38 as an emergency jumper.
                          For an AGM I would have chosen a Deka here in Australia, or a Kinetik or Deka in the USA. Though now I reckon I'd use a 100AH Yuasa UXH100-12 (it's cheaper than my UXH38-12)

                          Not that Optima's "rugged" design should impact its reliability. I think some people like them despite reality - one guy I know loves them despite 2 that failed within 3 months, and he only gets 3-5 years from the rest. (My circles have been getting 6-8 years life from batteries 20-25% the price of Optimas.)
                          And I won't comment on batteries that are generically suited to BOTH cranking and deep-cycle.


                          As to alternators...
                          If they are anything like the Bosch alternators I recently dealt with, I'm not surprised they blew.
                          But IMO alternators should be self limiting. The only "failure" I have had with my Jap alternators was relatively recently after one hour of load torture (unbogging my vehicle using a secondary UXH30 feeding a small winch and my cranking UXH30 cranking the engine in gear (with splugs in place but IGN disabled) and an occasional engine run for recharging & 14.4V winching whereby 2 minutes before freedom, the alternator failed. Subsequent autopsying revealed the alternator was fine EXCEPT that the regulator's sensing diode's solder-joint had melted due to the alternator's heat. But that is far from a normal situation - 1 hour with little air flow and extreme charging surges & demand (a 75A alternator, and one UXH38 takes 40-45A immediately after a mere cranking!).
                          BTW - re you reply in another thread, down here a rating is expected to be under normal operating conditions. Down here, a 90A rated alternator will be 90A at normal operating temperature, not when cold.


                          Re the combination of alts and batteries to remove audio headlamp flicker...
                          Just decrease the wire gauge to the audio. (Ha ha - ie, there are many solutions depending on the aim.)



                          And as to being subjective... I probably meant vague or lacking definition. Like what is an "Ultra high quality battery"? My $80 batteries are obviously better quality than the local $500 Optimas because mine last 8 years.
                          "Quality" is defined by the user, and varies with the application. Things like reliability, price, performance etc can be better defined or explained. But quality might be crap reliability, great performance, and price whatever that performance requires. Not that that's what I meant to refer to either...


                          But AFAIAConcerned, we are saying the same or similar things. Apart from Optima being crap (), paralleled batteries whilst charging is ok.
                          And thus things like "You do NOT want to use a Ultra high quality battery with a standard car battery" are meaningless or incorrect if referring to batteries that are isolated when not charging.
                          Oh, I didn't finish the "2 parallel batteries aren't quite 2x capacity". No, not if they are not equal - ie, one drags down the other. However, if discharged at the same rate as one battery was, the combined capacity will be more than 2x...


                          Funny how this makes me think if a line I often quote "Life's a poo. The you die."
                          And I think batteries account for much of that poo.
                          (I use poo because I don't think that word gets censored. But feel free to SHIfT in whatever word you feel appropriate. And with apologies to any reader that I may have just offended.)

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I'm running a dual-battery set-up with 2 Group 31 Optima Blue top's in parallel off of a White-Rodgers 12V 586 Series Solenoid (think High-Power Relay). I wired the coil on the solenoid to a 3-way switch so that in it's normal position, the solenoid claps shut when the engine is on (passes the accessory 12V's to the coil) and disconnects when the engine is off (or not in Accessory). Then, I can throw the switch to disconnect the 12V to the solenoid at all times, thus NEVER having the batteries connected, or into the 3rd position which puts 12V from the secondary battery into the solenoid coil, clapping it shut so that if my main battery dies, I can throw a switch and jump myself with my secondary battery.
                            The nice part about running it this way is that if I have the vehicle off, I can get about 3-5 hours out of my PC, depending on what I'm doing with it and still not touch my front battery.

                            My load is a 3930K CPU, 1GB Video Card, 3 SSD's, all off of an Opus 360 Pwr Supp, a 1000W monoblock pushing about 300W to a much too small 8", 650W amp pushing the 4 components, 1W wifi card, some misc. USB devices, and an Inelmatic XF1000 Monitor.

                            Isolating the batteries, as stated several times above, is definitely the way to go, both for safety and health of the batteries, as well as convenience in configurability (new word?). I didn't see if your secondary battery was a starter or deep cycle but I'm thinking that there may be an issue with mixing the 2 in a non-isolated set-up. There are also MOSFET style isolators that will allow you to always have both connected to the charging circuit but never to each other (popular in RV's).

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              IMO relays are better than MOSFETs. And cheaper.

                              Diode isolators - forget them. That's ancient technology which is large, expensive, and has problems since the batteries will be at different voltages.


                              Sizzlehappens is correct about mixing unmatched batteries when not being charged. Even keeping matched batteries connected (long term) when not being charged has problems - eg, if one fails it will fail the other battery.


                              IMO the best system is an alternator controlled relay - the charge light circuit energises a relay when the alternator is charging. (I have dubbed this method the "UIBI" or Ultimate Intelligence Battery Isolator. That name is to counter the so-called "Smart" or "Intelligent" voltage-controlled battery isolators. Their only smarts is in their marketing hype when not applied to systems that do not have a charge-lamp circuit (ie, an alternator/regulator D+ or L circuit).)

                              UIBI eg:



                              By including a diode between the D+ or L and the relay #86, other switching as described by shizzlehappens can be added - eg, a push button or switch bypass to manually connect the batteries; each switch or +12V source with its own diode (to prevent each +12V source powering the other sources and circuits).

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X