Quote: Originally Posted by elcapitan
Here u go, this one is from the 8 mile soundtrack.
All of those artist tags are different. AMP sorts hierarchically from Album -> Artist -> Songname.
AMP sees it as:
Artist: Eminem; Album: 8 Mile Soundtrack
Artist: Macy Gray; Album: 8 Mile Soundtrack
So it sees "8 Mile Soundtrack" as a unique Album for Enimen. And it sees "8 Mile Soundtrack" as a unique Album for Macy Gray.
This is necessary, because suppose you had the following:
Artist: The Rolling Stones; Album: Greatest Hits
Artist: The Doors; Album: Greatist Hits
If AMP grouped matching album names, then while it would work for the "8 Mile Soundtrack", it would screw up the listings for The Rolling Stones and The Doors.
This is a "limitation" of both AMP and iTunes (except iTunes has a view where it lumps all the same album names together, which would still fail for the Rolling Stones & Doors example above)
I had this problem a long time ago, with iTunes. I solved it like this, for Soundtracks.
Say the original Artist: Album: Song was:
The Shins : Garden State Soundtrack : New Slang
I changed it to:
Soundtracks: Garden State Soundtrack: The Shings - New Slang
So the "artist" tag is "Soundtracks" (and thus all of my soundstracks for movies are with this artist tag.) And the name of the soundtrack was the "album" tag. And then the artist - songname is the "song name" tag.
So I'll have like:
Artist: Soundtracks; Album: Garden State Soundtrack; Song:The Shins - New Slang
Artist: Soundtracks; Album: Garden State Soundtrack; Song: Coldplay - Dont Panic
...
Artist: Soundtracks; Album: The Life Aquatic; Song: Devo - Gut Feeling
... etc
It works really well for me, in both iTunes and AMP.